Tuesday, May 21, 2013

The Help


Like any other typical weekend my Grandmother and I try to go out to Breakfast and as always she chooses Snooze. For many of you that are not aware of this restaurant it is a cool 1970's themed place where the line always extends way out the door. As we were sitting there waiting for our order to be taken a family walks in with two small children, a white women and man, and then an African American women holding each of the children's hands. This is something I had never seen before up north, but in Cherry Creek this must be something prevalent. I thought to myself the connection between the African American woman and these two children is greater than the connection between the children and the parents. For instance the father was on the phone majority of the time "not to be disturbed" and the mother was constantly looking down at her phone as well as reading a magazine on Women’s Health. The woman was sitting between the two children coloring the color sheet and cutting up their food, waiting for it to cool down. This image was quite striking to me because i really felt sad for the children that their parents were way too busy than to raise these children on their own. Moreover, I think of the life the nanny lives, meaning where did she come from? Does she have children herself? Did she travel far to get here? 
 
In Introduction of Global Women by Barbara Ehrenreich it talks about the female underside of globalization. This piece was very eye opening to me especially when it went into the topic matter of how many rich and poor country households can rarely rely on males as the soul breadwinners. Women are needed out in the workforce to be able to provide for their families. In most other places aside from the United States women are forced to commute very far for work, and without their families. This was something that i found to be very shocking because this article even provided a story of a woman that had to travel and leave her family behind to be able to support her children. In turn usually they go work with families to raise their children and be their nannies. It is very upsetting because I am sure these women would love for nothing more than to raise their own children, but in fact having to raise another woman's as if they were her own. 
Moreover, something that I read that was quite surprising is the fact that before wealthy women used to flaunt their help and use them as wealth symbols. As for today the hired help is hidden and not as present as it was before. For women to show leisure was powerful but now women feel the need to employ the "super women" perspective. Which is the idea women that cooks, cleans, works, takes care if the children and the husband with grace. 
Another article that I was able to connect this situation to would be Real Men Join the Movement by Michael Kimmel. Through this article he talks about actively supporting women’s equality on the job or on the streets and by quietly changing their lives to create that equality at home. This statement alone made me think that if this was the case in third world counties would these women have to leave their homes to work for other families?? Would they be able to stay and raise their own children?? Why is it that the women have to travel and leave their children?? I mean Kimmel makes a good point when he said, “Men may oppressed by many things but gender is not one of them. For women they are oppressed from it all”. Do you see gender oppression frequently??? Work related??? Classroom related??? Also in popular movie from 2011 The Help which chronicles An aspiring author during the civil rights movement of the 1960s decides to write a book detailing the African-American maids' point of view on the white families for which they work, and the hardships they go through on a daily basis. For those of you that have watched this movie as well do you see the correlation??  Do you emphasize with these women? 

18 comments:

  1. Hi Jordan, very interesting blog post, thanks for writing on such an important topic that is not discussed in mainstream American culture. Toward the end of your blog you ask the interesting questions of, “This statement alone made me think that if this was the case in third world counties would these women have to leave their homes to work for other families?? Would they be able to stay and raise their own children??” Although I have not read that article by Kimmel to which you reference, I do not think men stepping up would be enough to stop or even decrease the number of women leaving the developing world to work in richer nations. I believe this because I think there are more structural and institutional problems here. For instance, the extreme poverty many developing countries face is a major push factor that forces women to migrate for domestic work. I think in order to truly improve conditions for women (and children and men) of the developing world there needs to be larger structural changes that take place that would allow for more economic opportunity within developing countries.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I couldn't agree more =) Thank you for responding!!!

      Delete
  2. Interesting post. I think this topic is very difficult to discuss in our society, because I think even Barbara Ehrenreich does not have the solution. Ultimately, I do not think there is one solution. Our country has been raised on the beliefs that women should be the caretakers and the stabilizers of the family. However, ultimately, a lot has changed for the better and for women to have more opportunities outside of the home.

    However, I believe there will always be a double standard for women even if they choose to work, to also be able to "do the housework." I am not sure I see the connection of the points you made to the family you saw at Snooze. Ultimately, many young parents choose to hire nannys now as they choose to also partake in a career. While the dad was busy working, clearly the mother must also have worked if they needed a nanny by her side. I think this is a lifestyle choice that is not necessarily fair to critique. Ultimately, how a family chooses to raise their children is an individual choice. I definitely think it reiterates the social construction of feminism and the role that woman are "supposed" to take in the home. However, I also know many young woman who want to be young mothers and care for their children as their job. Ultimately, it is a job, and a very difficult one.

    This topic has many different lens' to which we could look at it from, however, we still must deal with these issues on a daily basis as many new families are brought together.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I couldnt agree more!!! I feel there are numerous lenses that you could look at this through and could derive at different conclusions. Thank you for responding

      Delete
  3. Jordan, what an interesting article and interesting point you bring up in this blog. This is something that is very intriguing to think about. I loved how you referred to the movie "The Help" because I absolutely enjoyed that movie so much because of the points it made about our society as a whole. Our society has been raised to believe that women should be the nurturers and caretakers of the home and the men should be outside the home raising the money and being the supporters for the family. This role has changed in the last years because more and more women are beginning to work outside the home. They are becoming more and more independent and showing their true colors outside the home. I think that it is truly great but they need to be treated equally and not put down for making these decisions for their families.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I couldnt agree more!! The help was a real eye opener and then to read these articles allowed me to look deeper in the meaning. Thank you for responding

      Delete
  4. Hi Jordan! I liked your post! And I can totally see what you mean whereas in the past, nannies were flaunted and now they are so hidden. I think this has changed along with women's position in the workforce. Whereas in the past, women were more likely to stay at home, they were able to display their wealth by enlisting the help of nannies which was something they could afford but don't necessarily "need." Today on the other hand, nannies are needed often in order to keep families afloat and minimize chaos. Historically, people are unwilling to admit to their needs often to make themselves appear almost superhuman. "The Help" is a good example of this. The shocking thing to me is whereas before, the women were mistreated seemingly because they weren't necessarily needed, today they are still mistreated although they are extremely needed. This just goes to show that people will find ways to exploit less affluent populations knowing that they need the money.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you girl for the post!! I agree with the help being hidden!! It is a good point that you being up when you mention the women were mistreated seemingly because they weren't necessarily needed, today they are still mistreated although they are extremely needed.

      Delete
  5. Jordan, I really enjoyed your article. I cannot believe that a family went out to brunch and paid no attention to their children. Isn't brunch supposed to be a time for family?

    After reading the article we read for class, I have thought a lot about nannies in family life. As I have said before, I was raised by my parents and my nanny. However, my family did things a little bit differently. My mom said that my babysitter was my mom's friend before she was my babysitter. She also lives with her family and often took her children to work. My mom often encouraged her to get a new job when my siblings and I grew up. She was usually there during the week and when my parents went out. Even still, my parents were the primary adults that raised me.

    Still, I can see the inequality among our relationship. Abileene and the little girls relationship in the Help really reminded me of the relationship I had with my babysitter. We had the same tight knit relationship that they did. What made it this way?

    I really enjoyed your superwoman comment in your article. I think it could also be applied to the women with nannies. Women are now taught to get high paying jobs and to put children on the backburner. Women are kindof pressured into this kind of do everything mentality. But, like the article we read on the family, can women really have a job and take care of kids? I guess some people feel the pressure to get a nanny and unfortunately some people abuse that power.

    It is disheartening that these nannies are separated from their families just so their children can have a better life. Although I would never take away the family bond between my babysitter and I, it is also to realize that I am not her child. Her time with her children should take precedence over her time with me. Sadly, most nannies live far away from their families and thus, are not able to see them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for providing your personal story!! It is something i have never experienced and to read about your experience is great!! Thank you again and thank you for responding.

      Delete
  6. Great post Jordan. It's sad that as a woman, we can never really "have it all" without someone else's help. It kind of makes the "you can have it all" idea an illusion or something that we could never fully grasp. We've been lead to believe that with hard work and dedication, we can have it all (a happy family, a great career, etc), but in reality, we can't do it by ourselves. When other women are brought in to help, you'd think we'd be so grateful, but instead, we push them aside and ask them to hide when company comes around. Why are we embarrassed of the women who help us and have to put their own children and lives on hold simply to take care of someone else's? Why are we so ashamed to admit that it's difficult to juggle a successful career and take care of a household? These women help us, but yet we are not willing to give them credit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is really sad to think that you really could never "have it all". I think it is a big thing to bring up that these women help us so why be embarrassed? I would be proud and happy to show off the person that has helped raise my children. Thank you for responding!!!

      Delete
  7. Jordan, I really liked your post! Right now I am in a Human Migration class (if you're interested it is an Anthropology course) and we talk about these issues all the time. A huge reason that women leave is because they live in a place where, even if they have a job as a manager or a desk job, they would get paid more by migrating somewhere like Germany or the United States because work as a caregiver or cleaner pays more than their desk job. I've read the accounts of many women who feel great pain about not being able to be around their children, and even children who feel jealous because they know their mother is off taking care of another child. It can cause huge riffs in their families. A lot of the time these women don't come home for 8 or 10 years at a time! And while they are gone the responsibility of their children is passed to another female in the family. In a lot of cases this would make the women who migrated for work the breadwinner of their family. I wonder how that effects family atmosphere between a husband and a wife.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for the recommendation!! Also thank you for bring up the point of the children being jealous! I guess i have never thought about how they must feel.

      Delete
  8. I really enjoyed your post. I think it is really sad that they move here because it provides a better life for their families than actually living with their families. I think the Help was a good movie that did show this to be true, but because it was set in the 1960's, people do not relate it to actually being true now, even if it is. I did not realize this was the case, and it is frustrating to see how these employers treat these nannies, and can forget that it is their whole lives.
    One of my friends just moved to New York and I was discussing her nanny job with her the other day. She was telling me that her family has two nannies, and the other nanny is a woman from a South American country. She got really sick one day, and the mom got really frustrated that she lost her sitter last minute. This completely speaks to this issue of how a lot of the time they are not given paid time off, or any time off for that matter. It was really eye opening to see this actually happening.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wow thank you for sharing your personal story!! I never thought about time off and pay wages because majority of it dont go through the government, so how do we know if they are receiving the proper pay. etc. Let alone health insurance!!
      Thank you for responding

      Delete
  9. Hi Jordan! First off, I love "The Help!" How interesting that you saw this happening at Snooze. I definitely think that the children are probably closer with the nanny than the parents, just like in the movie. You start to wonder what the family background is, meaning if the parents both work full time or just one of the parents etc. It's hard to judge the family if the mother and father both chose to have a career and need a little help on the side; however it's sad to see both the parents so disconnected from their children. It's so true that these days help is hidden to imply the superwoman status but back then it was a symbol of wealth. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thank for the Blog! I love the movie The Help, me and my friend always say to each other: "You is smart, you is kind, you is important."
    I think towards the end, the questions you ask are addressing the push for these women to leave to find work, but don't address the pull of men in the US not taking on the 'second shift' and leaving it solely to women to be the superwoman. I think this issue can be more easily addressed in the first world countries where nannies need to have better rights, and need to be acknowledged as workers with paid time off, and technology availability to Skype with their families back home.

    ReplyDelete