Sunday, April 14, 2013

The Power in Doing Everything Alone

The role of the modern woman is a juxtaposition of her position in the family and her status in the hierarchy in the workplace. Many women have chosen to face the world by themselves and thus are required to accomplish tasks that would be designated partner activities such as parenting, cleaning, earning money, paying bills, and attending gatherings. These women frequently end up doing all the things rather than being able to designate these to a partner.
One of my favorite female bloggers Allie who writes Hyperbole and a Half (http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.com/p/about.html) and in one of her posts she speaks about the requirements of increased productivity with respect to her daily responsibilities in a blog post titled "Why I Will Never Be An Adult". As her number of responsibilities increases past the basic daily tasks, her productivity consistently decreases as a result of her increasing stress level as shown in her drawing below.
Patricia Hill Collins would would say that Allie identifies with her increasing work load as a form of oppression and she classifies her responsibilities as an adult as being types of oppression less important than her increasing workload (Collins, p.76). "Add(ing) together separate oppressions, you are left with a grand oppression greater than the sum of its parts (Collins, 77)." The addition of responsibilities to women's to do list causes a greater oppression based on their gender, financial position, stability of employment, and daily tasks that must be accomplished independently from others in one's social circle. 

Women's ability to accomplish their daily tasks depends on the safety of their person and integrity. In populations that follow the laws of Islam (the hadiths and the Q'uran), women who do not wear the Hijab (a veil or covering) may attract unwanted attention from a "uniquely masculine penchant for untamed sexual activity and construe the veil as God-ordained solution to the apparent disparities in men's and women's sexual appetites. Women are therefore deemed responsible for the management of men's sexuality (Read and Bartkowski, p. 246)." 

However Read and Bartkowski also claim that a woman may veil for reasons other than protecting against a man's sexual desires. In proponents views (Read and Bartowski citing Al-Swailem 1995 and Siddiqi 1983)"the veil can serve as a (1) demonstration of the Muslim woman's unwavering obedience to the tenets of Islam; (2) a clear indication of the essential differences distinguishing men and women; (3) a reminder to women that their proper place is in the home rather than in pursuing public-sphere activities; and (4) a sign of the devout Muslim woman's disdain for the profane, immodest, and consumerist cultural customs of the west." 

Perhaps women's choices to function in society without a partner are similar to some women's choices not to wear the Hijab in that both are rejecting the social expectations that partnership or religion that requires a union with another person is required to achieve one's full potential. Though women frequently find themselves exhausted when attempting to clear their to do list of tasks, their independence is a kind of payment for their successes. 

8 comments:

  1. First i want to start out by saying i really liked the way in which you correlated the article with this concept. Also when you stated, "Perhaps women's choices to function in society without a partner are similar to some women's choices not to wear the Hijab in that both are rejecting the social expectations that partnership or religion that requires a union with another person is required to achieve one's full potential". Was spot on and really and you think. I had never really realized that being with someone and having a partner to delegate these roles is in fact a social expectation. The idea of the "super woman" is coined from the fact that a woman needs to do everything and still maintain sanity. Overall i loved your correlations as well as your pictures.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It's so true how women end up doing it all! Even though we are trying to become these modern women, it seems like it is taking a long time for each partner to have the work divided equally. After reading the article "To Veil or Not to Veil" it made me think about how different life would be to have grown up in that culture. Maybe it would help to go through life veiled...or maybe not. It is interesting that as a society finding a partner is expected. Although it might be easier doing everything on your own, wouldn't it get lonely??

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think this is a great topic to address because of how relevant it is to college women! We're at a point in our lives where we're expected to pursue an education to launch future careers. It's assumed that because we're here, we value intelligence. The interesting component in all of this is the social sphere that coexists on a college campus. The pressure to maintain good grades, "health", and beauty is often felt by a lot of us. Juggling all of this, presumably alone, can feel overwhelming. While we may not foresee the need to sacrifice settling down with a significant other right now, we may be making other sacrifices. I really enjoyed this blog entry, and the visuals are great!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Bailey, I really like the way you took a broad topic of women facing the world's struggles, responsibilities, and expectations on their own and related it to the practice of veiling for Muslim women. To me, this shows that, just as Muslim women may choose to veil for particular reasons beyond the assumed and stereotypical reason of oppression, women can choose to live out their lives as single, strong, independent women who take on all the responsibilities and life struggles alone instead of feeling compelled or required to have a partner there beside them in order to function in Western society. Particularly, I liked your statement about how "the responsibilities on women's to do list causes a greater oppression based on their gender, financial position, stability of employment, and daily tasks that must be accomplished independently from others in one's social circle", yet how this "independence is a kind of payment for their successes." This truly shows how successful and driven women who choose to be independent in life really are and that we should pay more respect than we do to women who choose to independently move through life and society.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Today we see everywhere that women are the ones doing the cooking, cleaning, paying the bills, working, taking care of the family, and the list can seem endless! My Fiance and I talk about stuff like this a lot. Thinking about our future together we talk about different situations and how we want to approach them and deal with them. For example, who is going to stay home with the kids after they get home from school someday? Or who will take care of them the first few years of their lives before school comes around. Right now he has his career in the Air Force and I have my own aspirations that will not allow me to do both mom/caregiver/cleaner/cooker/etc AND follow my own dreams. I think it's interesting because there have been conversations where I brought up and proposed that I be the one working and he stay home with the kids. He is certainly more open now than he has been since I first brought it up, but I was taken aback by how against he was about it at first. It's not something that a lot of men ever think about growing up. Whereas a lot of women think about being a mom and being home all the time. So how do we find that balance so neither partner not feel like they are doing all the work alone? I'm not entirely sure but I guess that is part of figuring out life as we go.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you all for your comments on my post. I value that this topic has made an impact on your daily lives and I am pleased to find that I am not the only one who has come across this. I am glad many of you picked up on the veiling of Muslim women as a tool for their empowerment rather than a rule enforced at the hands of the men in their lives. I frequently have trouble finding balance in my life with my schedule working full time, attending school full time, taking care of my mother, and spending time with my boyfriend. The only things that get me through the craziness are cuddles from my lizard, slow days at work, good days with my mother, and time in on the weekend evenings with my boyfriend. Thank you all for your consideration and comments.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I really liked how you connected your current piece from the blog and related it to the "To Veil or Not to Veil" it really gives a sense to how the modern women is still pressured into not only fitting in with the stereotypes of women and being the motherly/in the home wife, but then trying to break those norms while also being dominating in the work place. I completely agree with the idea that women are doing it all, being mom and working mom and also being success at it. As a critique though I would have liked you to explain more how your bloggers ideas go with the ideas of "To Veil or Not to Veil", like specifically how does veiling or not veiling go with the idea that women are required to do so much more in today's time rather then staying with traditions or straying from them. Overall though I thought this was a well written blog that connected our classes readings and was current with today's time, good job.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I would say that your article did the best job of connecting with the readings. A really, really good job! I also liked that you chose to write about something other than weight like most of the other articles on here. It was a very interesting read and I found the muslim "To Veil or Not to Veil" one of my favorite readings of the unit. Your connection of the hijab and the process of veiling was very unique and thought-provoking. I had never thought about that before. I agree with you that a woman being independent and a muslim women not veiling have a lot of similar effects as far as social status and stress. However I would say that the hijab issue is a lot more serious. A lot of americans want women to become more independent and self-sustainable - even if that puts more workload on the women. Whereas, as far as I can tell, very few Muslims in their home-countires want women to be unveiled. Just a thought but great job with the readings and concept!

    ReplyDelete